Indian & Buttles Streets Corridor Study

Final Public Input Collected at January 11, 2021 City Council Meeting


At its first meeting of 2021, the Midland City Council provided residents and M-20 corridor users with the opportunity to share their feedback in a final public comment session on Monday, January 11. For a recap of this meeting, watch the 'What's Up in the City!' video above.

To view the full Council meeting, including public comment, please watch the January 11, 2021 City Council meeting below. (Discussion on the corridor begins at the 1:34:30 mark)

January 11, 2021 - Final Public Comment Received for Future of Buttles Street Corridor



Next Steps: Final Discussion, Decision to be Held at January 25 Council Meeting

Following the collection of its final round of public input at the January 11, 2021 City Council meeting, Council is anticipated to provide discussion and issue a final directive to the Michigan Department of Transportation (MDOT) at its meeting on January 25, 2021 at 7 p.m. via Zoom. Attendance information for this meeting will be posted here when it is available.

All public comments received to date will be taken under advisement as the City and MDOT consider potential redesign options ahead of the corridor’s anticipated reconstruction in 2024. 

MDOT shared its final results of the 18-month road diet trial and its impacts on vehicle speed, volume, and traffic delays at the November 23, 2020 City Council meeting. You can find these results and more info by scrolling down to "Recent Updates".

Click here to view a full document that details all Council action and presentations related to the Buttles Street road diet trial to date. These documents and corresponding videos can also be found independently throughout this page, so please continue reading and look around!

Background on the Study

A red SUV, white truck, and other vehicles drive through the Buttles Street road diet trial area

In May 2018, Midland City Council approved a 3-year lane reduction study of Buttles Street. This study temporarily barricades the far right lane of Buttles Street from M-20/Jerome Street to State Street in an effort to observe how the road would function as a two-lane street. During the 3-year study phase, the Michigan Department of Transportation (MDOT) will periodically monitor the study area to observe four key factors of roadway service level: traffic speeds, traffic volume, traffic accidents, and traffic delays and back-ups. 

Prior to the 2018 study being approved by City Council, MDOT also conducted several multi-day test closures on portions of Buttles Street in August 2017 and November 2017 prior to suggesting a full-scale trial be implemented. Monitoring first took place after a 6-month period in 2018, then proceeds to occur annually from the May 2018 through the end of the trial period. Throughout the study period, MDOT representatives and City staff report current data findings and observations to City Council and the general public at scheduled City Council meetings.

To view documents, presentations, and videos related to these findings, see the "City Presentations" sidebar.

Why consider a "road diet" in this area?

As MDOT and the City of Midland reviewed the 2015 study and planned for the future of our community, several goals were identified for the Indian and Buttles street corridors:

  • Improve safety for motorized and non-motorized transportation users
  • Encourage economic development in the corridor
  • Improve inter-neighborhood connectivity and mobility
  • Develop a corridor that better reflects current roadway design standards and best practices for both motorized and non-motorized uses

In each consideration, lane reductions have proven to be an effective tool utilized by transportation engineers and urban planners to meet these conditions. Keep reading to learn more about the vision for this corridor, the "whys" behind the study, and updates on current study data. You can also find a helpful list of documents on the right sidebar (desktop) or bottom of the page (mobile) to find public meeting presentations, study documents, and more.

Where did this idea begin?

Beginning in 2015, MDOT commissioned a study with consulting firms MKSK Studios and DLZ to analyze the entire US 10 Business Route corridor in both directions from Washington Street to Airport Road. The final study report, presented to Midland City Council in March 2017, included observations from consultants and public input collected by MDOT as well as a list of viable alternative options for improving traffic flow and pedestrian usage through the corridor. One of these options included a lane reduction on both Indian and Buttles streets in the current road diet trial area. Click the links below to see more information related to the US 10 BR Corridor Study.

Related items:

Video: History of the Indian & Buttles Street Corridor

If you're a newer resident to Midland, you might be surprised to learn that Buttles and Indian haven't always been three-lane thoroughfares. Watch the video above to learn more about the history of this corridor and why, now, it may make sense for a lane reduction to take place.

Recent Updates 

November 2020: MDOT Returns to Council to Provide Post-Trial Statistics

At its November 23, 2020 City Council meeting, the Midland City Council received an update from MDOT on traffic, safety, and delay statistics that it compiled in the Buttles Street corridor following the conclusion of the road diet trial. Additional traffic monitoring and data analysis was conducted in November 2020 to ascertain how traffic was navigating the corridor as a three-lane roadway.

Key findings:

  • The road diet trial had no significant impact on traffic safety (crashes), vehicle speed, and mobility for motorists (delays/transit times through the corridor) because data during the trial was very similar to that collected both before and after the trial was implemented;
  • The number of accidents recorded both during the trial period were almost exclusively attributable to driver behavior, not roadway size or design;
  • The number of accidents recorded in this corridor each year, including during the trial period, are very minimal and almost too small to properly record a trend;
  • The roadway saw no traffic delays during or after the road diet trial; and
  • In the opinion of MDOT traffic experts, Buttles Street can function safely and effectively as both a two-lane and a three-lane roadway in this area

City Council received and filed this information, with no decisions being made at this meeting. MDOT has indicated that it plans to revamp the Buttles Street corridor in the next 3-5 years and will begin design considerations in January 2021 with input from City Council about its desire for the future of Buttles, whether as a two-lane or a three-lane road. City Council is anticipated to discuss this project in more detail and make a formal recommendation to MDOT about the community's desire for the future sometime prior to this timeframe, but no formal date has been set at this time.

Watch this "What's Up in the City!" to get an overview of the meeting, then check out the full meeting video below. Discussion of the road diet begins at the 2:45:00 mark.

Click here to download a PDF version of MDOT's presentation.

What's Up in the City!: Road Diet Trial Update, November 25, 2020

City Council Meeting - November 23, 2020



November 2019: Council Requests Trial End 

At its November 18, 2019 City Council meeting, the Midland City Council discussed the future of the Buttles Street road diet trial. At that time, Council voted to request that MDOT complete the current road diet trial by the end of the calendar year 2019. If MDOT believes additional data is needed to successfully end the trial, Council has asked that MDOT provide what additional data is needed and an estimated time frame for completion. On Thursday, November 21, City Manager Brad Kaye sent a letter to MDOT reflecting Council's position.

A letter from City Manager Brad Kaye to MDOT regarding the Buttles Street road diet trial

Click here to read a copy of the letter

It is anticipated that MDOT will attend an upcoming City Council to provide the most recently-collected study data and make its recommendation about the future of Buttles Street.

Watch the video below beginning at the 1:02:25 mark to listen to Council discussion regarding the road diet trial.

City Council Meeting - November 18, 2019


December 2019: MDOT to Remove Bollards, Conclude Trial Period

On December 9, 2019, MDOT responded to the City Council's letter asking for the trial period to conclude by the end of the calendar year. In its letter, MDOT indicates that it is satisfied with the amount of data collection received during the trial period and will return Buttles Street to a 3-lane configuration by the end of December 2019. MDOT will conduct additional data collection in January 2020 after the return to a 3-lane configuration and, following the conclusion of this data collection period, will return to City Council in February or March 2020 with a final analysis of all data collection and recommendation to Council. At that time, Council will make a decision regarding the future of the Indian and Buttles corridors.

MDOT to City - Road Diet Trial End Letter 12.9.19

Click here to read a copy of the letter

Watch the Council meeting below to hear a discussion about MDOT's letter and the end to the road diet trial period. The discussion begins at the 50:05 mark.

City Council Meeting - December 9, 2019


What is the study trying to address?
Overhead photo of vehicles sitting at the corner of Jerome and Buttles

At the highest level, the Indian & Buttles Corridor Study is just that - a study to determine if Buttles Street can function as a two-lane road. However, the study is a part of an overall vision to transform Indian and Buttles streets into an area of the community that's functional and safe for all users - vehicles and pedestrians - while encouraging economic growth and development, neighborhood connectivity, and increased non-motorized use.

Lane reductions are conducted in communities throughout the United States for a variety of reasons. The current Indian & Buttles Corridor Study seeks to address six key factors that are vital to the future success of our downtown corridor and, to a larger extent, the entire community:

  • Traffic
  • Safety
  • Economic Development
  • Non-motorized Mobility
  • Connectivity
  • Context Sensitive Design/Solutions

For more information on each of these factors, please click on the tabs below to pull up more details. (The tab you're currently viewing will be shown in green; additional tabs available to be clicked will be shown in gray.)

  1. Traffic
  2. Safety
  3. Economic Development
  4. Non-Motorized Mobility 
  5. Context Sensitive Design
  6. Connectivity

Corridor Traffic

Since 2017, MDOT has observed the road diet trial area several times to understand how the road is performing:

  • August 28 - 30, 2017
  • November 6 - 13, 2017
  • September 25 - 28, 2018
  • October 12 - 14, 2018
  • March 3 - 9, 2019
  • April 28 - May 4, 2019
  •  May 7 – 8, 2019
  • October 2-5, 2019
  • November 11-14, 2020

When conducting roadway studies, MDOT and the City are analyzing four areas: vehicle speed, traffic volume, back-ups and delays, and accident data. Metrics for the first three areas are collected on-site by MDOT, while the fourth is provided by the Midland Police Department and other local agencies. Let's take a look at the most recent data for each area. Previous data collections can be found in the Council presentations with the corresponding date under the "City presentations" heading or at the bottom of this container under "Related Items".

This section was updated November 25, 2020.

Traffic Volumes

Traffic volumes in the Buttles Street corridor have remained relatively consistent during the road diet trial as they have in previous years. Recent field counts found 13,875 vehicles per day at Jerome Street in 2018, right around the 5-year average volume, and a slight increase of about 1,100 vehicles per day at State Street. Volumes for the past 9 years as provided by MDOT are listed below:

Monitor location201820172016201520142013201220112010
SE of Jerome St
13,785
14,581
12,902
12,369
13,564
13,364
13,739
13,150
14,278
SE of State St13,520N/A11,89211,24712,62412,54113,12312,34112,605


Updated volumes for 2019 and 2020 can be found in the "Vehicle Speeds" graphic listed below.

Vehicle Speeds

At its most recent presentation to Midland City Council in November 2020, traffic analysts at MDOT detailed a traffic volume and speed data comparison to the corridor with the roadway as a two-lane road (2019) and a three-lane road (2020). The data compiled found that speeds were 1-2 mph slower under two-lane conditions and that daily traffic volumes were considerably lower in 2020 as a three-lane road. (This could be due to remote work and other impacts as a result of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic.)

A graph of vehicle speeds recorded in 2020 by MDOT

Traffic Delays & Back-ups

Traffic delay studies identify the number of vehicles that are left waiting at a signalized intersection through more than one light cycle. During MDOT’s delay studies in November 2020, May 2019, September 2018, and November 2017, no traffic delays in the road diet trial area were found.

Vehicle Accidents

In 2019 when the road diet trial was in place, the corridor saw 34 traffic crashes. From January 1 to October 3, 2020, the corridor saw 22 traffic crashes as a three-lane roadway. In both years, the majority of traffic crashes were caused by a motorist running a red light on Buttles or a cross-street. Other than two rear-end collisions recorded in 2019, which are accidents commonly attributed to delivery issues with the roadway's design, every accident recorded in both 2019 and 2020 can be attributed to driver behavior and not roadway design.

According to traffic analysts at MDOT, these numbers are extremely small data points and year-over-year accident numbers in the corridor are so low that it's difficult to apply any positive or negative trends to these numbers. 

Buttles Street Road Diet - Crashes by violation 2019-2020


Buttles Street Road Diet - Crashes to date, 2020

Related Items

Public Input: Meetings and Information Sessions

In addition to regularly-scheduled City public meetings, additional opportunities for public involvement have also been implemented during the road diet trial. 

Public Information Session & Walking Tour - August 14, 2019

Two public information sessions and walking tours of the corridor were held on Thursday, August 8 and Wednesday, August 14 at City Hall that covered an overview of the proposed trial, current data and statistics, and an opportunity for attendees to experience the corridor on foot and share their feedback. Watch the video below to see the August 14, 2019 meeting.

Related items:

City Council Community Conversation - September 18, 2019

On Wednesday, September 18, a special meeting of the Midland City Council was held at Memorial Presbyterian Church in Midland to facilitate a community conversation between City staff, residents, the Michigan Department of Transportation, and Council. City staff provided an overview of the study, followed by attendees' forming small groups to discuss the six objectives of the study to provide feedback, ask questions, and offer suggestions. Watch the video below to view the meeting.


Related item:

E-CityHall Online Public Survey

In Q3 2019, residents residents and M-20 corridor users were encouraged to share their input with City staff and the Midland City Council on the City's E-CityHall public engagement platform. The results, which include over 170 responses and 9.5 hours of estimated public input, can be found here

Click here to download the complete E-CityHall survey report.

Future vision for the corridor

Now that we've covered the reasons why this trial has been executed, let's address the next question: What would Indian and Buttles streets look like if they were taken down to two-lane roads? If the road diet trial were to be implemented, we’d rely on the public’s input to help shape the actual design, but MDOT provided some potential options for this corridor at its 2016 US-10 Corridor Study open house that residents were able to discuss. Find them below.

US-10 Corridor Study - Options


ARTICLE: Can less be more?

A screenshot of an article by Catalyst Midland Opens in new window

What are we looking to accomplish through this road diet trial? City staff sat down with Catalyst Midland to talk about our vision for the future of Buttles and Indian streets that could become a reality if the road diet trial proves successful. Click the image above to read the article.

Frequently Asked Questions

If you still have questions about the road diet trial after reviewing the information above, please look through a few of our FAQs to see if your question has been asked before!

View All

Contact Us

  1. Grant Murschel


    Director of Planning and Community Development
    Email Grant Murschel

    Midland City Hall
    333 W Ellsworth Street
    Midland, MI 48640

    Phone: 989-837-3374

    Hours


    Monday - Friday
    8 a.m. - 5 p.m.

    Staff Directory