- Residents
- Indian & Buttles Road Study
- Buttles & Indian Corridor Improvements
Buttles & Indian Corridor Improvement Project
About the Project
(Current project updates appear under this section)
In January 2021, the Midland City Council passed a resolution to support the redesign of the Buttles Street corridor from Jerome Street/M-20 to State Street from three vehicular travel lanes to a two-lane profile. This action followed an 18-month trial study May 2018 - December 2019 conducted by the Michigan Department of Transportation (MDOT) that temporarily reduced Buttles Street from three lanes to two lanes.
The future goals for the Buttles corridor developed jointly by the City of Midland and MDOT include:
- Improve safety for motorized and non-motorized transportation users
- Encourage economic development in the corridor
- Improve inter-neighborhood connectivity and mobility
- Develop a corridor that better reflects current roadway design standards and best practices for both motorized and non-motorized uses
Buttles Street Road Study Information
As the trial period is over and action by the Midland City Council has committed to a two-lane road profile for Buttles Street, information from the 2018-2019 Buttles Street "road diet" trial will not be updated here. All information related to the study, including a history of the study, traffic and safety data, actions by the Midland City Council, and public input collected during the trial period can be found on the Indian & Buttles Street Corridor Study page.
PROJECT UPDATE:
Buttles Street Preliminary Design Open House Hosted by MDOT Held July 20 at City Hall
On Wednesday, July 20, 2022, Michigan Department of Transportation (MDOT) staff held a public open house in City Hall Council Chambers to review preliminary designs for Buttles Street; discuss the tentative project timeline; and provide information on planned traffic control measures during construction. Attendees at the meeting asked questions, talked with staff, and provided input on the designs and information shared during the meeting.
Click here to download the PowerPoint Presentation (PDF)
Project Details
The Buttles Street redesign will include reducing Buttles Street to a two-lane road profile as well as non-motorized improvements, street lighting upgrades, signal modernization, aesthetic streetscape updates, and (potentially) the movement to underground utilities. This project is estimated to cost $33.5 million and be completed in one construction season beginning in 2025.
Current Project Schedule:
- Base plans prepared - April 2022 (completed)
- Public & stakeholder input meetings #1 - July 2022 (completed)
- Preliminary plans prepared - January 2023
- Public & stakeholder input meetings #2 - Spring 2023
- Final plans prepared - Early 2024
- Construction begins - 2025
Preliminary Project Designs
In each section below, you'll find a slideshow of images with a brief description of the images you see. Click on each image in the slideshow to view a PDF packet with larger-resolution designs and information. The caption on each image will reference the page where it can be found in each PDF packet.
Not sure what you're looking at? Don't worry! We'll be covering these designs and more in a chat with MDOT in the next episode of Word on the Street(s) in August. Keep scrolling to learn more about this podcast.
Road Design Overlays (Click the images to view)
These images show preliminary plans for the road profile on both Indian/Buttles and Patrick/Lyon streets from M-20/Jerome Street to Washington Street. Features on these images include a decreased turn angle from M-20/Jerome Street onto Buttles for commercial and semi-trailer vehicles; right turn lanes at the Gordon, Ashman, and Cronkright; enhanced pedestrian crossings at State Street; and more.The new road profiles are indicated with solid black lines.
Cross-Section Design Perspectives for Buttles & Indian (Click the images to view)
These designs show reimagined design perspectives at cross-sections of Buttles and Indian streets with various cross streets through the corridor. Updates include increased green space, aesthetics, and improved non-motorized connectivity.
Options for Improving Non-Motorized Corridor Use (Click the images to view)
These designs show reimagined design options along the Buttles Street corridor that would provide increased space for green space, trees, and non-motorized pathways. Options include replacement of existing sidewalks along the new road profile and designs that consider the movement of overhead utilities underground.
Traffic Control During Construction (Click the images to view)
These images show MDOT's planned approach to traffic control during the reconstruction of Buttles Street as a two-lane profile, as well as alternative traffic control methods that were considered. The part-width construction approach requires no temporary widening, minimizes negative impacts to the area, and reduces construction time. Some traffic backups are expected during peak hours.
Provide Public Comment
Residents whom have reviewed the information above and want to provide public comment to MDOT can do so via the following methods:
Jack Hofweber
Mt Pleasant TSC Manager
hofweberj@michigan.gov
(989) 239-2681
Word on the Street(s) - A Corridor Improvement Podcast
Launched in February 2021, Word on the Street(s) is a podcast from the City of Midland that explores the future of the Buttles and Indian Corridor Improvement Project. Episodes are co-hosted by Communications Coordinator Katie Guyer and Director of Planning & Community Development Grant Murschel, with special guests including City staff, road design experts, and more. Topics will include recent updates on the projects' progress, public input opportunities, and discussions of the design and vision for the corridor moving forward.
Word on the Street(s) is released on the third Thursday of every month on the City's YouTube channel and as an audio-only podcast on most preferred podcast platforms. Video replays are also available on MGTV-188 (Charter) and 99 (Uverse) and available on-demand on the Roku and Apple TV streaming apps. Additional special episodes may be released as the project progresses.
Latest Episode: Season 3 Episode 1 - A Two -Way Conversation, April 27, 2023
In our first episode of Season 3, Director of Planning and Community Development Jacob Kain joins host Katie Guyer to recap recent public open houses on the Ashman and Rodd two-way conversion initiative, including revisiting the "why" behind the project, an overview of what they heard from residents, and next steps for additional public input and decision making.
Episode List
Click the links below to access previous episodes of the podcast via video on YouTube.
Season 3
Season 2
- Episode 1: More Than One Way (to Design a Street) - January 20, 2022
- Episode 2: Love Where You Live (& How to Make It) - February 17, 2022
- Episode 3: If You Build It - April 14, 2022
- Episode 4: Meet & Greet (& Designs for Streets) - July 15, 2022
- Episode 5: An Update with MDOT - August 2, 2022
- Episode 6: What's Up in (Center) City! - October 20, 2022
- Episode 7: A Very Merry Modern Master Plan - December 22, 2022
Season 1
- Episode 1: And Then There Were Two (Lanes) - February 18, 2021
- Episode 2: Let's Talk About (Complete) Streets - March 18, 2021
- Episode 3: Safety in the Corridor (and Beyond) - April 26, 2021
- Episode 4: An Update (with MDOT) - May 20, 2021
- Episode 5: Fact or Fiction (Roadway Edition) - June 17, 2021
- Episode 6: Fact or Fiction (Roadway Edition) Part 2 - July 22, 2021
- Episode 7: Walking the Talk - September 27, 2021
- Episode 8: A Little Bit of Context (Sensitive Solutions) - November 18, 2021
Episode Extras
Click the tabs below to access extras referenced during each episode.
Season 3
Episode 1 - A Two-Way Conversation: April 27, 2023
In our first episode of Season 3, Director of Planning and Community Development Jacob Kain joins host Katie Guyer to recap recent public open houses on the Ashman and Rodd two-way conversion initiative, including revisiting the "why" behind the project, an overview of what they heard from residents, and next steps for additional public input and decision making.
OHM Study Overview
The study conducted by civil engineering firm OHM Advisors examined Ashman and Rodd Streets from numerous viewpoints, including traffic operations, traffic speeds, non-motorized mobility, navigability, and more. The comparison of one-way vs. two-way traffic for each area of focus can be found in the chart below.
A link to the full study can be found under the "Episode Links" section below.
Traffic Counts: Major Streets in a Similar Context (2022)
The graph below shows daily vehicle traffic counts for intersections of Ashman and Rodd compared with other major street intersections in the city that have a similar context (environment and use) to the one-way pairs. In many cases, Ashman and Rodd see similar or even lower traffic volumes than major two-way streets. Click here for a PDF version of this document.
Sample Two-Way Design Slideshow
As no final decisions have been made on this project, these designs are provided solely to give corridor users an idea of what a two-way profile could look like on these streets. Click here to view a larger PDF version of these images.
Episode Links
Check out the links below for more information on items referenced in this episode:
- Ashman & Rodd Conversion project information
- Public input topic: Ashman & Rodd Two-Way Conversion
- (Open for comment through May 10, 2023 at 7 a.m.)
- OHM Advisors: Ashman & Rodd Conversion Study (2022)
- Start with the Streets: How Anyone Can Make Their City Safer & Wealthier One Block at a Time (Strong Towns, 2021)
- The Many Benefits of Making One-Way Streets Two-Way (Bloomberg City Lab, 2015)
- Two-Way Streets Can Fix Declining Downtown Neighborhoods (Planetizen, 2014)
Season 2
Episode 1 - More Than One Way (to Design a Street): January 2022
In this episode, Katie and Grant discuss Ashman and Rodd streets, another set of one-way pairs that span from Downtown to Center City, and their future as either two-way or one-way streets. The discussion includes characteristics of these corridors and why their future is critical to the pending reconstruction projects on Buttles and Indian streets.
Check out the links below for some of the topic points discussed in the episode, as well as examples of previous one-way to two-way conversions:
- One-Way to Two-Way Street Conversion (City of Lansing, MI - 2022) (PDF)
- "Cities Benefit from Restoring Two-Way Traffic" (Congress for New Urbanism, 2019) (PDF)
- "The Small Indiana City That's Embracing Livable Streets" (Streetsblog USA, 2014)
- Chinatown One-Way Street Conversion Study (City of Oakland, CA - 2009) (PDF)
- Conversion of One-Way Street Pairs to Two-Way Operations (City of Birmingham, AL 2008) (PDF)
- City of Midland Master Plan - Chapter 6: Transportation (PDF)
- City Modern Master Plan Update - Transportation Resources
- Midland Downtown Development Authority - Support of One-Way to Two-way Conversion (Video, 2:50 mark)
Episode 2 - Love Where You Live (& How to Make It)
In this season's second episode, Katie and Grant welcome Richard Murphy of the Michigan Muncipal League to talk placemaking, quality of life initiatives, and the impact that infrastructure projects - including road diets and street improvements - can have on the connection between people and the places and space where they live. They also discuss several exciting placemaking projects by MML members throughout the state of Michigan.
Segment 1 - Streets as a Public Space
In Segment 1 of this episode, Grant and Katie discuss a recent Strong Towns article that challenges the traditional metrics used in street design: speed and volume. A link to this article can be found below.
Segment 2 - The Art of Placemaking ft. Richard Murphy, Michigan Municipal League
In Segment 2 of this episode, Michigan Municipal League Policy Research Labs manager Richard Murphy joins the podcast to talk all things placemaking: what it looks like, how it impacts economic development, and why it's so important for communities to find ways to connect people with the places they live. The group also discusses several great placemaking projects from MML member communities around the state, including the Downtown Allegan, Michigan Riverfront Development and the Cadillac, Michigan Heritage Plaza. Both case studies are provided in the link below, as well as graphics for each project.
- Creating 21st Century Communities: The Economic Case for Place - 2016 (PDF)
- Michigan Municipal League: A Decade of Placemaking in Michigan - 2017 (PDF)
- Michigan Main Streets: Winter Strategies for Downtowns & Business Districts - 2020 (PDF)
- Community Investment, Community Growth: A Retrospective in Michigan Crowdfunding - 2019 (PDF)
- Michigan Municipal League PlacePlans: A Community Collaboration - 2013 (PDF)
Episode 3 - If You Build It
In this month's episode - and Grant Murschel's last with the podcast - the team talks to Midland City Engineer Matt Lemon about the 2022 City construction schedule; how the City's roads are funded and maintained; and the challenges faced by today's civil engineers when planning and supporting a street network.
Check out the links below for more information on some of the topics discussed in today's episode.
Episode extras:
Episode 5: An Update with MDOT
In this latest episode, Katie is joined by Michigan Department of Transportation (MDOT) Projects & Contracts Engineer John Kelley to review preliminary project designs, a construction timeline, and more initial details on the Buttles Street Corridor Improvement Project that were shared during the July 20, 2022 public open house.
Episode extras:
The Buttles Street redesign will include reducing Buttles Street to a two-lane road profile as well as non-motorized improvements, street lighting upgrades, signal modernization, aesthetic streetscape updates, and (potentially) the movement to underground utilities. This project is estimated to cost $33.5 million and be completed in one construction season beginning in 2025.
Current Project Schedule:
- Base plans prepared - April 2022 (completed)
- Public & stakeholder input meetings #1 - July 2022 (completed)
- Preliminary plans prepared - January 2023
- Public & stakeholder input meetings #2 - Spring 2023
- Final plans prepared - Early 2024
- Construction begins - 2025
Preliminary Project Designs
In each section below, you'll find a slideshow of images with a brief description of the images you see. Click on each image in the slideshow to view a PDF packet with larger-resolution designs and information. The caption on each image will reference the page where it can be found in each PDF packet.
Not sure what you're looking at? Don't worry! We'll be covering these designs and more in a chat with MDOT in the next episode of Word on the Street(s) in August. Keep scrolling to learn more about this podcast.
Road Design Overlays (Click the images to view)
These images show preliminary plans for the road profile on both Indian/Buttles and Patrick/Lyon streets from M-20/Jerome Street to Washington Street. Features on these images include a decreased turn angle from M-20/Jerome Street onto Buttles for commercial and semi-trailer vehicles; right turn lanes at the Gordon, Ashman, and Cronkright; enhanced pedestrian crossings at State Street; and more.The new road profiles are indicated with solid black lines.
Cross-Section Design Perspectives for Buttles & Indian (Click the images to view)
These designs show reimagined design perspectives at cross-sections of Buttles and Indian streets with various cross streets through the corridor. Updates include increased green space, aesthetics, and improved non-motorized connectivity.
Options for Improving Non-Motorized Corridor Use (Click the images to view)
These designs show reimagined design options along the Buttles Street corridor that would provide increased space for green space, trees, and non-motorized pathways. Options include replacement of existing sidewalks along the new road profile and designs that consider the movement of overhead utilities underground.
Traffic Control During Construction (Click the images to view)
These images show MDOT's planned approach to traffic control during the reconstruction of Buttles Street as a two-lane profile, as well as alternative traffic control methods that were considered. The part-width construction approach requires no temporary widening, minimizes negative impacts to the area, and reduces construction time. Some traffic backups are expected during peak hours.
Provide Public Comment
Residents whom have reviewed the information above and want to provide public comment to MDOT can do so via the following methods:
Jack Hofweber
Mt Pleasant TSC Manager
hofweberj@michigan.gov
(989) 239-2681
Episode 6 - What's Up in (Center) City!: October 2022
In this latest episode, Katie is joined by Community Affairs Director Selina Tisdale to discuss the Saginaw Road Streetscape Renovation project that kicked off in August 2022 and aims to redesign the corridor and improve access for non-motorized and pedestrian users.
A New View: S. Saginaw Road
A sample schematic drawing of what the reconstructed S. Saginaw Road corridor will resemble is shown above. Project features include 8-foot multi-modal pathways, improved lighting, driveway access improvements, aesthetic lighting and horticulture features, and new street trees.
Check out the links below for some of the topic points discussed in the episode, as well as examples of previous one-way to two-way conversions:
Episode 7: A Very Modern Modern Master Plan - December 2022
In this episode, Director of Planning and Community Development Jacob Kain shares an update on a recent City Council action related to Buttles Street, provides context on an upcoming decision for Ashman and Rodd streets, and goes into detail on the progress of the Midland City Modern Master Plan update, including some obvious examples of Master Plans in our daily lives and even a few previous Master Plan ideas that didn't come to fruition (Downtown Midland as an indoor shopping mall?).
Check out these images from the 1972 Master Plan discussed on the podcast:
Relevant Links
Check out the links below for some of the topic points discussed in the episode:
Season 1
Episode 1 - And Then There Were Two (Lanes): February 2021
Preliminary Design Sketches for Buttles
In this episode, Grant and Katie discuss preliminary design options for Buttles that were shown to City Council in January 2021. Check them out in greater detail below! (Click the images to view a full-sized rendering.)
Buttles at Jerome Street
Buttles at Townsend & Cronkright
Buttles at Ashman
Episode 2 - Let's Talk About (Complete) Streets: March 2021
In the first segment of this episode, Grant and Katie discussed the Complete Streets Act of 2021. Click on the links below for more information about this Congressional legislation
- Read the Complete Streets Act of 2021 (PDF)
- Smart Growth America explains - The Complete Streets Act of 2021
In the second segment of this episode, City of Ferndale Planning Manager Justin Lyons discussed an ongoing lane reduction project with MDOT on Woodward Avenue in Ferndale. Check out some schematic drawings of this project below. (Click the images to view a full-sized rendering.)
More information on this and the other City of Ferndale projects discussed in this podcast episode can be found at FerndaleMoves.com.
Episode 3 - Safety in the Corridor (and Beyond) - April 2021
In the first segment of this episode, Grant and Katie discussed recent traffic crash at Jerome and Buttles streets that resulted in a vehicle striking the Pathfinder Commons multi-unit housing complex at this intersection. Check out the slideshow below for photos of the crash scene and the damage caused by this accident.
Later in Segment 1, Grant mentions the Midland City Modern Master Plan update, which will focus on neighborhoods and livability and transportation and mobility as key points in the master planning process. This update will include lots of opportunity for public input, so check out the website below and learn more about this process and how you can become involved!
Episode 4: An Update (with MDOT) - May 20, 2021
In this episode, both hosts Katie and Grant and our guests from MDOT mentioned the 18-month road diet trial study that collected data to determine if Buttles Street could function as a two-lane roadway. To view this data and public input collected during the trial, visit the Indian & Buttles Road Study page.
Episode 7: Walking the Talk - September 27, 2021
In the first segment of this episode, hosts Katie and Grant discuss a series of recent accidents in the Indian and Buttles corridors, including a synopsis of general location and what that might mean for safety of all users. You can view this report below.
The report lists crashes recorded by the Midland Police Department from January 1, 2019 - September 1, 2021. The Buttles Street lane reduction trial ended in December 2019, so any crashes recorded in the Buttles corridor after December 2019 occurred after the roadway returned to a three-lane profile. Each crash is listed individually under the street on which the incident occurred, then by date and time. The most recent crash is listed first.
Click here to download the Indian/Buttles Crash Report (PDF) |
To view accident data collected during the entire lane reduction trial, visit the Indian & Buttles Road Study page.
In a later segment, Katie and Grant review a list of new and enhanced pedestrian crosswalk locations submitted to the Michigan Department of Transportation (MDOT) throughout the entire corridor for consideration in the new Buttles Street redesign. You can find maps of those proposed locations below. Click on the photos to file a larger file.
Proposed Crosswalk Locations & Enhancements - West Segment (Buttles/Indian)
Proposed new crosswalks:
- Buttles at Fitzhugh
- Indian at Fitzhugh
- Indian at Cronkright
- Indian at State
- Indian at Haley
Proposed enhanced crosswalks:
- Jerome at Buttles
- Buttles at State
Proposed Crosswalk Locations & Enhancements - East Segment (Patrick/Lyon)
Proposed new crosswalks:
- E. Patrick at Pine
- E. Patrick at Bayliss
Episode 8 - A Little Bit of Context (Sensitive Solutions): November 2021
In this episode, guest John Martin references the Multi-Modal Development & Delivery (M2D2) Guidebook used by the Michigan Department of Transportation to ensure that road projects include context sensitive solutions from planning through implementation. A link to this guidebook is below, as well as a link to the MDOT website that contains a list of CSS-inspired projects by region.
In the second segment, Katie and Grant briefly discuss the City's Master Plan update process, City Modern, that is currently underway. To view more information about this process, find public engagement survey results, and learn more about how to get involved, visit the City Modern link below.
So What's Next?
Residents will not see changes to this corridor for some time, as the project will now enter the design phase at MDOT with input and assistance from City staff as necessary. Design concepts and other elements on the redevelopment of this roadway will follow in the months and years to come with opportunities for the public to provide feedback when appropriate.
MDOT anticipates that the corridor will see reconstruction during the 2024 construction season, at which time the road profile will be transitioned into two lanes for motor vehicles. Until that time, the corridor will remain three lanes. A final design concept for this corridor has not been determined yet, so check back to this page frequently for updates as the design process progresses.
For the latest updates and other discussion of the project as it progresses, check out the City's Word on the Street(s) podcast on the third Thursday of every month on YouTube, Facebook, and your podcast platform of choice.